Composite vs. Amalgam Fillings: Which Is Better?

Side-by-side comparison of a tooth-colored filling and a silver amalgam filling

The main difference between composite and amalgam fillings is that composite fillings are tooth-colored resin that bonds to the tooth, while amalgam fillings are silver-colored metal. Composite blends in with your natural teeth, which is why many patients choose it, especially for teeth that show when they smile.

If you have a cavity, or older silver fillings you are curious about, it helps to understand how these materials compare. This article covers appearance, durability, the procedure and what to discuss with your dentist. The right choice depends on the size and location of the cavity and your overall dental health.

What Is a Composite Filling?

A composite filling is a tooth-colored resin used to repair a tooth after decay is removed. It is matched to your natural shade and bonds to the tooth. The material is placed in layers, shaped to fit your bite, hardened with a special light and polished. Chelsea Family Dental offers composite dental fillings that are designed to look natural and resist staining.

What Is an Amalgam Filling?

Amalgam, often called a silver filling, is a mixture of metals that has been used in dentistry for a long time. It is known for being durable, but it does not match tooth color. Over the years, amalgam fillings can look darker, which many people find unattractive when they smile or laugh.

Composite vs. Amalgam: Side-by-Side Comparison

Appearance

Composite is matched to your tooth shade, so it is hard to see. Amalgam is silver and noticeable, especially on teeth near the front of the mouth.

How the filling attaches

Composite bonds directly to the tooth. Amalgam is held in place mechanically, which often means shaping the tooth to lock the filling in.

Durability

Both materials can last for years with good care. Chelsea Family Dental notes that composite fillings can last about 7 to 10 years, and how long any filling lasts depends on its size, where it is in the mouth, your bite and your home care.

Setting time

Composite is hardened with a light before you leave the office, so it is set right away. Waiting until numbness wears off before eating is still a good idea so you do not bite your cheek or tongue.

Advantages of Composite Fillings

  • Natural, tooth-colored appearance
  • Bonds to the tooth
  • Resistant to staining
  • Can be used to replace older, darkened fillings for a more even smile
  • Set immediately with a curing light

Is Amalgam Safe?

This is a common question. Amalgam contains mercury, and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has recommended that certain higher-risk groups, such as pregnant women and young children, avoid new amalgam fillings when appropriate alternatives are available. The FDA does not recommend removing amalgam fillings that are in good condition, because removal can disturb healthy tooth structure. If you have questions about your existing fillings, talk with your dentist rather than having them replaced automatically.

Should I Replace My Old Silver Fillings?

Not necessarily. A filling that is intact and not causing problems may be fine to leave in place. Replacement may make sense when:

  1. The filling is cracked, worn or leaking
  2. There is new decay around or under it
  3. The tooth is painful or sensitive
  4. You want a more natural look, and your dentist agrees it is a reasonable option

Your dentist can check old fillings at your regular exam and let you know if any need attention. For signs that a tooth needs a new filling, read signs of a cavity and how fillings fix them.

How to Make Any Filling Last Longer

Whichever material you have, everyday habits affect how long a filling holds up:

  • Brush twice a day with fluoride toothpaste and clean between teeth daily.
  • Limit frequent snacking and sugary drinks, which feed decay around the edges of fillings.
  • Avoid chewing ice, hard candy and pens.
  • Ask about a night guard if you grind or clench your teeth.
  • Keep up with regular exams so worn or cracked fillings can be caught early.

What to Expect When Getting a Filling

The area is numbed first, so the procedure should be comfortable. After decay is removed, the composite is placed, shaped and polished. Mild sensitivity to hot and cold for a few days is common and normally settles. The procedure time depends on the tooth and the size of the cavity. Most dental insurance plans cover all or part of a filling, and Chelsea Family Dental can review your coverage.

Key Takeaways

  • Composite fillings are tooth-colored and bond to the tooth. Amalgam fillings are silver-colored metal.
  • Both can last for years with good care.
  • Intact amalgam fillings usually do not need to be removed.
  • Your dentist can recommend the best material for each tooth.

Ask About Tooth-Colored Fillings

If you have a cavity or old fillings you want checked, call Chelsea Family Dental at (617) 887-1400 or book an appointment online. The office is at 38 Central Ave, Chelsea, MA 02150 and accepts MassHealth for all ages.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which lasts longer, composite or amalgam?

Both can last for years. Chelsea Family Dental notes that composite fillings can last about 7 to 10 years, and lifespan depends on the size and location of the filling, your bite and your home care.

Does Chelsea Family Dental use composite fillings?

Yes. The practice offers composite fillings that are matched to your natural tooth shade, so they blend in with your smile.

Should I have my silver fillings removed?

Not automatically. The FDA does not recommend removing amalgam fillings that are in good condition. Your dentist can check whether any old fillings are worn, cracked or have new decay around them.

Does getting a composite filling hurt?

The tooth is numbed first, so the procedure should be comfortable. Mild sensitivity to hot and cold for a few days afterward is common.

Share this post?

Recent Posts

News Latter

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)